nadia-rahmawati
Canadian media projections indicate that the sovereigntist Parti Québécois (PQ) has secured a minority victory in Monday's provincial election in Quebec, positioning Paul St-Pierre Plamondon as the province's incoming premier. The result marks the first time the PQ has held power since 2014, and it introduces a fresh challenge for Prime Minister Mark Carney as he seeks to maintain national cohesion.
The outcome sets the stage for potential confrontations between Quebec's new government and Ottawa on a range of contentious issues, including immigration policy and the future of the monarchy in Canada. More significantly, the PQ has committed to holding a referendum on Quebec's independence, a promise that could reshape the country's political landscape in the coming years.
The majority French-speaking province has twice before voted on the question of sovereignty, in 1980 and 1995, with both referendums ultimately failing. Current polling suggests that only about 30% of Quebecers support independence, a figure that raises questions about the viability of another plebiscite. Plamondon has nonetheless pledged to pursue the vote, though he has indicated it would take place only after US President Donald Trump leaves office.
Trump is due to depart the White House in roughly two years, meaning that if Plamondon honours his commitment, a third referendum on Quebec independence would likely be scheduled for 2029 or 2030. The timing reflects a calculation that external political factors could influence the debate, though the PQ leader has not elaborated publicly on why Trump's tenure is relevant to the scheduling.
Carney may find himself managing simultaneous unity crises in different regions of the country, depending on the outcome of a separation vote in Alberta later this month. That province's upcoming plebiscite, combined with Quebec's renewed sovereignty push, could place unprecedented strain on the federal government's ability to hold the country together.
Beyond the question of independence, Plamondon has signalled a willingness to challenge Ottawa whenever it is perceived as overstepping into provincial jurisdiction. During the campaign, he suggested he would pressure the federal government on immigration matters, vowing to resist any increases mandated by the Carney administration.
The PQ leader has also pledged to "abolish the monarchy in Quebec" and redirect funding currently spent on its institutions toward social services. Speaking to reporters in late September, he said his government would "do what we have to do to get the monarchy out of Quebec, repatriate those funds, and send them to social causes."
As a concrete example, Plamondon proposed defunding Quebec's lieutenant-governor's office, which represents King Charles III in the province, and using that money instead to address homelessness. Such a move would mark a significant departure from constitutional convention and would likely provoke a legal confrontation with federal authorities.
The lieutenant-governor plays a central role in Canada's constitutional framework, including the responsibility of granting royal assent to new legislation. Withdrawing financial support from that office would put the validity of future Quebec laws in doubt, creating a constitutional crisis that could end up before the courts.
Pressed on these potential hurdles, Plamondon has told reporters he is prepared for a legal battle with the federal government. His stance reflects a broader willingness to test the limits of provincial authority, even at the risk of destabilizing the federation.
Plamondon's position on the monarchy is not new. In 2022, he was among a group of Quebec lawmakers who refused to pledge allegiance to the King, a act of defiance that ultimately paved the way for a provincial law making the oath of allegiance optional. That legislative change signalled a growing willingness within Quebec's political class to distance the province from the Crown.
The PQ's success on Monday can be attributed in part to public fatigue with the previous Coalition Avenir Québec government. That party had made safeguarding Quebec's identity and language central to its eight years in office, but its longtime leader, François Legault, eventually lost significant support among voters.
Efforts to revive the party by replacing Legault with a new leader, outgoing Premier Christine Fréchette, proved unsuccessful. Fréchette conceded her own re-election race in Trois-Rivières shortly before 22:00 local time, and in a speech she said she would work with St-Pierre Plamondon on the transition. "Governing Quebec is the greatest honour I have ever had," she said. "I have Quebec tattooed on my heart."
The Quebec Liberal Party secured the second-most seats in the election, while the Quebec Conservative Party gained seats, according to projections. The results suggest a shifting political landscape in the province, with voters opting for change after nearly a decade of CAQ rule.
Prime Minister Carney, who leads the federal Liberal party, remains popular in Quebec, though support for him had recently dipped following the imposition of new US tariffs on Canada in August, which came after a breakdown in trade talks. Quebec is among the provinces hardest hit by those tariffs, with experts at global forecasting firm Oxford Economics projecting a C$2bn blow to the provincial economy.
Carney congratulated Plamondon on his victory late on Monday and vowed to work together with the new government. In a post on social media, he said, "Building a stronger Québec is core to our mission of building a stronger Canada." He added that he looked forward to supporting Quebec's businesses and workers affected by tariffs, creating jobs, addressing homelessness, and expanding housing construction across the province.
The coming months will test whether Carney's conciliatory approach can bridge the deepening divide between Ottawa and Quebec's new sovereigntist government. With a referendum potentially on the horizon and legal battles looming over the monarchy and immigration, the relationship between the two levels of government is poised to become one of the most closely watched political dynamics in Canada.
Comments (0)